Case file · PCAG
SUBJECT: Amish, Mennonite & Plain communities
STATUS: Open to new consultations
Understanding Plain Communities from the Inside
Most people only see Amish, Mennonite, and other Plain communities from the outside. What actually shapes life inside them is much harder to see: the unwritten rules, who holds authority and how it’s used, the weight of family and church, and the very real reasons someone may never ask an outsider for help.
Plain Culture Advisory Group brings firsthand knowledge and professional expertise to investigations, legal proceedings, training, and other situations where understanding the culture can make a difference.
Entry 01 — Who we are
Beyond what you can google
Some things about Plain communities can’t be learned from a search bar. You can research Amish and Mennonite beliefs, traditions, and history, but understanding how those things play out in everyday life—and how they can influence an investigation, legal case, or professional interaction—is something else entirely.
That’s where our experience comes in.
We help law enforcement, attorneys, social workers, researchers, journalists, and other professionals navigate cases and situations involving Amish, Mennonite, and other conservative Plain communities. Our work brings cultural context to the things that aren't always obvious from the outside—community expectations, family relationships, church authority, and the barriers that can make it difficult for someone to speak up or seek help.
Our team brings together current and former Plain women and allied professionals with firsthand knowledge, lived experience, and professional expertise to help you recognize what might otherwise be missed, ask more informed questions, and better understand the people and circumstances involved.
On Record
Agencies we’ve worked with and trained
Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation (BCI)
Homeland Security Investigations (HSI)
Ohio Governor's Human Trafficking Task Force
Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)
Our team has also co-authored IRB-approved research on child abuse in Plain communities.
OUR BELIEF
Understanding culture
Changes Outcomes.
Entry 02 — What we can do
Who we help
Courts & legal professionals:
Cultural context, community records, and expert insight for prosecutors, defense attorneys, guardians ad litem, and judges.
read the full entry→
Exhibit A
Child protective services
Help serving Plain families and protecting Plain children, from barriers to disclosure to culturally informed safety planning.
read the full entry→
Exhibit B
Researchers
Cultural guidance, ethical outreach, and study design support from people who know these communities firsthand.
read the full entry→
Exhibit C
Law enforcement
Training and case consultation, plus help locating community documents and mapping the churches, families, and social hierarchy behind a case.
read the full entry→
Exhibit D
Media
Accurate, responsible reporting on Plain communities: background, context, credible sources, and care for survivors who speak out.
read the full entry→
Exhibit E
Anti-trafficking & advocacy
Recognizing exploitation hidden behind tradition, including labor and sex exploitation, and building outreach that reaches Plain individuals.
read the full entry→
Exhibit F
Field note
Document Retrieval
Plain communities document far more than most outsiders realize: church directories, genealogies, community publications, family records. We know where to look, and we help connect those records to the people, families, and churches involved in a case.
Entry 03 — Open a consultation
Let's talk about what you're working on.
Whether you're navigating an active investigation, preparing your team for work in a Plain community, conducting research, or trying to report a story responsibly, we're here to help you work through the cultural context and questions that come with it.
Not sure exactly what kind of support you need? That's okay. Tell us a little about the situation, and we can start there.
All inquiries are kept confidential.